Search Forums
Forums
Kiwitrees on Twitter
    Tags

    living, request, age, ID notes, media_links, custom modules, immigration, folder, statistics, last change date, autocomplete, GEDCOM, pages, google, census, relationships, server, session, check, timeout, batch update, 3.1.1, white screen, data errors, individual resource, reports, media, set link, merge, Relationship, FAQ, illegitimate, 3.0.0, colors theme, Default record, emmigration, edit, language, follow, getClientIp, admin, .mo, transifex, errors, slideshow, error, index, configure, add missing death, research, resources, beta, tools, translate, pdf, access roles, add, default individual, ID facts, Require visitor authentication

    Topic:   PLAC  

    This topic contains 3 replies, has 2 voices, and was last updated by macalter macalter 2 years, 3 months ago.

    Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
    • Author
      Posts
    • #4090
      macalter
      macalter
      Participant

      536 posts

      When a place is near another place, do you include “near …”?

      1 PLAC Kensington Town, near London, England (made up)

      1 PLAC Kensington Town, England
      2 ADDR near London

      I know I’ve not been the most consistent with entries I’ve had (as given in the Source), but seeing in the Royals GEDCOM, makes me wonder.

      -----
      Kiwitrees:
      "A-D connections 3.3.0 (rev)"
      PHP 5.6.29 Fast CGI

      "The Royals 3.3.0.."
      PHP 7.0 Fast CGI
      mySQL server: 5.1.56
      MacOS: 10.11.6  (El Capitan)
      Browsers (mac): Safari  Version 10.1.1 (11603.2.5);  Firefox 53.0.2
      [updated: 22 May 2017]

      #4091
      kiwi
      kiwi
      Keymaster

      1443 posts

      Well, technically you can do anything you want. But I wouldn’t do that. For me a place is an exact location (and used for Google Map) . Saying it is “near” somewhere is neither part of a PLAC definition nor part of an ADDR unless (very rare) it really is a VALID / OFFICIAL part of the postal address.

      If it is useful information it should be in a NOTE, i.e. ” 2 NOTE Kensington Town is near London” – which is the absolutely correct use of a NOTE – a short / brief addendum to a fact or event record.

      Nigel

      My personal kiwitrees site is www.our-families.info

      #4092
      kiwi
      kiwi
      Keymaster

      1443 posts

      🙂

      …. and if you think about your precise question: “When a place is near another place, do you include “near …”?”, then you should put “near ….” in EVERY PLAC record, because everywhere is “near” somewhere!!

      Nigel

      My personal kiwitrees site is www.our-families.info

      #4093
      macalter
      macalter
      Participant

      536 posts

      Most of the “near” ones for part of my tree go way back when locating a place was by saying it was near some known town – early 19th C. If I find in GeoNames website, I drop the “near” from PLAC. I don’t use Google Maps but keep that in mind. ADDR vs NOTE, hear you but will stay consistent in use for that.

      Will do a check that all are removed when I return to my own file. And if I’m doing edit for Royals record anyway, will modify.

      -----
      Kiwitrees:
      "A-D connections 3.3.0 (rev)"
      PHP 5.6.29 Fast CGI

      "The Royals 3.3.0.."
      PHP 7.0 Fast CGI
      mySQL server: 5.1.56
      MacOS: 10.11.6  (El Capitan)
      Browsers (mac): Safari  Version 10.1.1 (11603.2.5);  Firefox 53.0.2
      [updated: 22 May 2017]

    Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

    You must be logged in to reply to this topic.